Results
- Prevalence of secondary dystonia
How common is secondary dystonia? Prevalence data on secondary dystonia are limited. A Brazilian study of 122 patients with a dystonic syndrome, 46 (38%) were found to have a symptomatic form.
2 Among these, the most frequent causes were tardive dystonia (35%) and perinatal cerebral injury (30%). Other causes included stroke (13%), encephalitis (6.5%) and Wilson’s disease (4%). Causes were more common in certain age groups: Younger patients tended to have had perinatal cerebral injury or encephalitis preceeding their dystonia. In older patients stroke and exposure to drugs (tardive dystonia) were more common. In a recent study by Wenning et al.
3 of 16 elderly patients with dystonia, ten (62.5%) were classified as having a secondary form of dystonia. Of these, eight were drug-induced, highlighting the importance of this etiology. This is in line with a large study of more than 3,000 dystonia patients, 29% of which had a secondary form:tardive dystonia was the leading cause.
4,5
However, in addition to tardive dystonia, there are a number of other secondary and heredodegenerative disorders which can cause dystonia as a predominant feature or as part of a syndrome. Certain clinical clues may help to narrow down the list of differential diagnoses and focus the investigations accordingly (
Table 1).
- Clinical clues
Dystonia with prominent oro-bulbar involvement
Some primary dystonias there may have laryngeal involvement, for example DYT4 (“whispering dystonia”, the underlying gene remains unkown), DYT6 (due to mutations in the THAP1 gene, as very recently identified), DYT12 (“rapid-onset dystonia parkinsonism”) and DYT17 (recessively inherited, linked to the chromosome 20, gene not yet identified) dystonia.
6–
8 However, overall, prominent oro-lingual-buccal dystonia is uncommon in primary dystonia and a secondary or heredodegenerative form should be considered,
9 particularly, when severe (
Table 1). In particular pervious neuroleptic intake, but also certain genetic disorders such as PKAN (pantothenate kinase associated neurodegeneration, previously known as Hallervorden-Spatz disease) due to mutations of the PANK2 gene, neuroacanthocytosis, neuroferritinopathy and Lesch-Nyhan syndrome are high on the list of differentials.
10 With the exception of neuroferritinopathy (autosomal dominant inheritance) they follow autosomal recessive inheritance and family history may thus be negative for a similar disorder, but there may be a history of consanguinity.
Eye movement disorders
Patients with primary dystonia have normal eye movements. In fact, presence of an eye movement disorder hints towards a secondary form of dystonia.
Eye movement dysfunction may be in the form of supra-nuclear gaze palsy. Patients with a supranuclear gaze palsy may complain of difficulties going downstairs because of limited downward gaze which is usually more affected than upward gaze. Presence is limited to a few dystonic conditions, most importantly progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP), where parkinsonism is the prominent and patients are elderly. Furthermore, supranuclear palsy may be present in Niemann-Pick type C and PKAN, both inherited autosomal recessively. In Niemann-Pick type C, a neurovisceral lipid storage disorder, supranuclear gaze palsy is present in 75% of adult-onset cases and a presenting sign in 8% of cases.
10
Dystonia and retinitis pigmentosa
The presence of retinitis pigmentosa in the context of dystonia narrows down the list of differential diagnoses. Most important differential diagnoses in this context are PKAN (or the allelic disorder referred to as HARP syndrome characterized by hypoprebetalipoproteinemia, acanthocytosis, retinitis pigmentosa, and pallidal degeneration), GM2 gangliosidosis and metachromatic leukodystrophy.
Dystonia and deafness
The combination of dystonia and deafness is characteristic of the Mohr-Tranebjaerg syndrome due to a new mutations in the DDP1 gene.
11 Other mitochondrial disorders may produce a complex phenotype which may involve additional visual problems (blindness) or heart problems.
12
Another complex disorder with phenotypic similarities to mitochondrial disease is the Woodhouse-Sakati syndrome. For this, only recently the underlying cause was identified and effects the C2orf37 gene, encoding a nucleolar protein.
13 This rare autosomal recessive disorder presents with hypogonadism, alopecia, diabetes mellitus, mental retardation, and extrapyramidal features.
14 As for other genetic disorders, there is phenotypic and genetic variability.
Dystonia and peripheral neuropathy
Presence of neuropathy is not a feature of primary dystonia, although subclinical impairment of sensory discrimination is discussed as possible endophenotype of dystonia.
15
If ataxia is additionally present, there are, however, a number of differentials to consider. This includes the common recessive forms of ataxia, such as Friedreich’s ataxia
16 and ataxia telangiectasia
17,18 and their differential diagnoses,
19 where ataxia, dystonia and peripheral neuropathy may be present. For example, in a study of 70 ataxia telangiectasia patients, dystonia was present in 55 and peripheral neuropathy 50 of them.
20 A less common cause is the young-onset variant of Niemann-Pick type C disease, while the adult form presents with peripheral nervous system involvement.
11 Because presence of vertical gaze palsy is also characteristic (see above) in Niemann-Pick type C, which is present in 75–80% of patients, this can be a helpful clue towards the diagnosis. A further clue may be enlargement of the liver and spleen (present in about one 30–90% of cases)
11,21 and, in children, neonatal jaundice (present in half of the patients).
Notably, the combination of dystonia with neuropathy and ataxia can also be seen in some of the autosomal dominant spinocerebellar ataxias,
22 e.g. SCA 3.
23
Finally, the combination of peripheral neuropathy, progressive dystonia and ataxia, as well as cognitive decline is seen in metachromatic leukodystrophy caused by mutations in the arylsulfatase A gene cause.
24
Dystonia and parkinsonism
In addition to pure dystonic and pure parkinsonian syndromes, there are overlap syndromes. On one hand dystonic conditions may have superimposed parkinsonism as seen in dopa-responsive dystonia or Wilson’s disease. On the other hand, dystonia may be a seen in (or even be the presenting feature of) various parkinsonian disorders.
While dystonia is uncommon in drug-naive patients with idiopathic Parkinson’s disease, its presence may be a red flag towards an atypical parkinsonian syndrome like PSP, multiple system atrophy (MSA) or corticobasal degeneration (CBD).
25 Dystonia may then present as axial dystonia and blepharospasm (levator inhibition) causing the starring expression associated with PSP; antecollis and facial dystonia in MSA; or the dystonic arm posture seen in CBD.
Parkinsonism associated with dystonia is furthermore characteristic of genetic forms of parkinsonism which often have young-onset and recessive inheritance (for review see).
26,27 One example is parkinsonism related to mutations in the Parkin gene where dystonia may be present intermittently, as so-called exercise-induced paroxysmal foot dystonia, and this may precede signs of parkinsonism by some years.
28 The combination of young-onset dystonia and parkinsonism is also seen in other neurodegenerative diseases like the rare autosomal recessive disorders of nigro-striatal-pallidal-pyramidal syndrome referred to as Kufor-Rakeb disease and PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration (PARK14).
29 (also see review by Schneider, et al.
26)
Most frequent, however, is dystonia in the context of parkinsonism as complication of dopaminergic treatment, for example as peak-dose dystonia, diphasic dystonia and offdystonia.
28
Dystonia with progressive dementia
Progressive dementia is not a feature of the primary dystonias like the young-onset DYT1-related dystonia or the adult-onset sporadic forms. Progressive dementia is, however, one of the core features of Huntington’s disease and the Huntington disease-look like syndromes (including HDL4/SCA17), as well as neuroacanthocytosis and PKAN. Indeed, chorea is the main movement disorder, however, prominent dystonia can occur. A further condition to consider is Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, a rare neurodegenerative disease characterized by rapidly progressive dementia, mutism, ataxia and extrapyramidal and pyramidal involvement.
30 The movement disorder is typically characterized by focal or generalized myoclonus (present in 80–100% of cases), but dystonia occurs and may rarely be a presenting sign.
30–
32 Dystonia in Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease is then usually unilateral and distally but may become generalized in later disease stages.
30 Over all, disease course is rather progressive and this should alert the clinician to this diagnosis. Furthermore, HIV encephalopathy is a cause of dementia; and dystonia has also been observed.
33
Finally, dementia may also be a symptom in the complex autosomal recessive dystonia parkinsonian syndromes mentioned above.
26
- Clues from neuroimaging
Neuroimaging can reveal patterns characteristic of certain conditions. Strategic lesions in the basal ganglia, brainstem, cerebellum or cortical areas (parietal and frontal) may result in dystonia
34–
41 and there may be a relationship between the distribution of dystonia and the localization of the lesion. For example, it has been proposed that thalamic lesions are more likely to result in hand dystonia. However, not all basal ganglia lesions necessarily result in neurological symptoms or signs. Brainstem lesions on the other hand have been associated with cranial dystonias such as blepharospasm, and putaminal lesions were found in patients with hemidystonia or limb dystonia. In hemidystonia, lesions are often unilateral, contralaterally to the dystonia.
Of course, the list of causes underlying the lesion is long and includes tumors, trauma, bleeding, inflammation, atrophic changes in the context of neurodegeneration or accumulation of metals (such as iron, copper, manganese etc.).
How imaging can facilitate the diagnostic work-up we will be discussed in more detail as an example for basal ganglia disorders with metal deposition. The basal ganglia host high concentrations of metals which act as cofactors for metabolic activity including iron, copper and manganese. In the case of excessive metal accumulation, this may cause dysfunction and disease.
Metal deposition can be detected by neuroimaging on CT (e.g. copper) or MRI (e.g. iron). In recent years, in particular, iron deposition has received growing attention and a new term referring to these disorders, “syndromes of neurodegeneration with brain iron accumulation” (NBIA), has been coined. This group entails the condition of PKAN (NBIA type 1, also known as Hallervorden-Spatz disease), PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration (NBIA type 2),
29 neuroferritinopathy, and aceruloplasminemia.
42,43
Of these, in PKAN iron accumulates within the globus pallidus interna. T2-weighted MRI demonstrates a signal hypointensity representing iron with a central hyperintensity (probably representing fluid accumulation or edema) and this pattern resembles an eye of the tiger on axial slides.
42 It has been proposed that this ‘eye-of-the-tiger’ sign highly correlates with the genoptype, thus with presence of PANK2 gene mutations,
42,44 and that it is usually present from early in the disease course,
45 although this is still matter of debate. NBIA type 2 is associated with mutations in the PLA2G6 gene on chromosome 22q13, a calcium-independent phospholipase. The clinical phenotype is heterogenous and includes infantile neuroaxonal dystrophy and adolesecence-/adult-onset dystonia parkinsonism, and it is a key differential diagnosis of PKAN. As in PKAN there is iron deposition on MRI imaging, however there is no classical eye-of-the-tiger sign, but there is only a hypointensity in the globus pallidus, whereas the central hyperintensity is lacking. Notably, though, normal MRI imaging has also been reported in a gene-proven case of PLA2G6-associated neurodegeneration and the disorder should thus also be considered when iron is absent.
29
Copper deposition also shows as hyperintense signal on T2-weighted scans. Copper deposition in the putamen and globus pallidus, liver and cornea are characteristic of Wilson’s disease, an important differential diagnosis of secondary dystonia, particularly in young patients.
46,47 This is known as “face of the giant panda” sign (referring to the combination of high signal intensity in the tegmentum except for the red nucleus with preservation of signal intensity of the lateral portion of the pars reticulata of the substantia nigra and hypointensity of the superior colliculus).
48
Manganese accumulation has been associated with secondary parkinsonism in welders chronically exposed. In the basal ganglia manganese accumulates symmetrically within the globus pallidum and is depicted as hyperintensity on T1 sequences. Dystonia may also be prominent.
49–
52
Calcium deposition can be easily detected by CT imaging as high-intense lesions and incidental calcifications are relatively frequent (up to 1.5% of CT scans). Within the basal ganglia, calcium mostly commonly affects the globus pallidus and is usually benign, in most cases idiopathic or age-related.
53 In view of this, it has been proposed that presence of globus pallidus calcifications only requires further elaboration when the patient is younger than 40 years of age. In addition all patients, no matter of age, where other basal ganglia or brain areas are affected should be further investigated. The differential diagnosis is wide and includes metabolic, infectious, toxin-induced and degenerative causes.
53 Among the metabolic disorders, idiopathic or surgical hypoparathyroidism is probably the most common cause of symmetric basal ganglia calcification, and dystonia as presenting feature may occur.
54 Infections (including congenital forms) by toxplasmosis, rubella, cytmomegaly, herpes and HIV may result in basal ganglia damage with calcifications and secondary dystonia.
55,56 Following carbon monoxide poisoning movement disorders including dystonia may develop as a part of delayed encephalopathy
57 and imaging may reveal basal ganglia calcifications.
58 Neurodegenerative causes include Wilson’s disease.
59
Last but not least, familial causes of basal ganglia calcifications have been recognized, also referred to as striopallidodentate calcinosis or Fahr’s disease and dystonia has been observed.
59